CME Bitcoin buying and selling quantity surpasses Bybit, however is it impacting BTC value?

by Jeremy

The Chicago Mercantile Alternate (CME) launched its Bitcoin futures contract in December 2017. This was across the identical time that Bitcoin (BTC) had reached an all-time excessive of $19,800, however by late 2018, the worth had dropped to $3,100. Traders in cryptocurrencies rapidly discovered that CME spinoff contracts allowed them to make bullish bets with leverage but additionally enabled them to wager in opposition to the worth, a follow often known as shorting.

Traditionally, the Securities and Alternate Fee has rejected Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) proposals because of issues about manipulation on unregulated exchanges. The rising significance of CME’s Bitcoin futures market would possibly tackle this subject, and not too long ago, Hashdex has even requested a Bitcoin ETF that depends on Bitcoin’s bodily trades inside the CME market.

Skilled merchants usually use BTC derivatives to hedge dangers. For example, one can promote futures contracts whereas concurrently shopping for BTC utilizing borrowed stablecoins utilizing margin. Different examples embody promoting longer-term BTC futures contracts whereas buying perpetual contracts, which may assist a dealer profit from value discrepancies over time.

CME overtook Bybit to turn into the second-largest BTC futures market

CME has performed a key position within the Bitcoin futures market since 2020, amassing a formidable $5.45 billion in open curiosity by October 2021. Nonetheless, over the next years, the hole widened, as CME’s Bitcoin futures market reached $1.2 billion in January 2023, trailing behind exchanges like Binance, OKX, Bybit and Bitget.

Extra not too long ago, the Bitcoin value dropped by 12.8% between Aug. 16 and Aug. 17, resulting in a $2.4 billion discount within the mixture futures open curiosity. Notably, CME was the one alternate unaffected when it comes to open curiosity. In consequence, CME turned the second-largest buying and selling platform on Aug. 17, with $2.24 billion in BTC open curiosity, in line with knowledge from CoinGlass.

Bitcoin futures open curiosity rating. Supply: CoinGlass

It’s value noting that CME completely gives month-to-month contracts, which differ from perpetual or inverse swap contracts, essentially the most traded merchandise on crypto exchanges. Moreover, CME contracts are at all times cash-settled, whereas crypto exchanges present contracts primarily based on each stablecoins and BTC. These distinctions contribute to the distinction in open curiosity between CME and crypto exchanges, however there’s extra to the story.

CME futures present discrepancies relative to crypto exchanges

Except for variations in contract settlement and the absence of perpetual contracts, the buying and selling of Bitcoin futures on the CME diverges considerably from most crypto exchanges when it comes to each quantity and pricing dynamics. The CME information a mean day by day quantity of $1.85 billion, which falls wanting its $2.24 billion open curiosity.

In distinction, Binance’s BTC futures see a day by day quantity nearing $10 billion, thrice better than its open curiosity. A comparable sample is noticed on the OKX alternate, the place day by day buying and selling in BTC futures reaches about $4 billion, surpassing its $1.4 billion open curiosity. This variance could be attributed partially to CME’s greater margin requirement and the fee-free buying and selling surroundings for market makers on crypto exchanges. Moreover, CME’s buying and selling hours are constrained, with a halt from 4:00 pm Central Time to five:00 pm and a full closure on Saturdays.

Nonetheless, varied components contribute to cost distinctions in comparison with different exchanges. These embody shifts in demand for leverage amongst lengthy and brief positions, together with potential disparities within the Bitcoin index value calculation throughout totally different suppliers. Lastly, it’s essential to think about the solvency dangers related to the tie-up of margin deposits (collateral) till the BTC futures contract settlement.

Associated: When will or not it’s too late to put money into Bitcoin?

December 2023 BTC futures, CME (blue) vs. Binance (orange) vs. Bybit (cyan). Supply: TradingView

Notably, CME Bitcoin futures have traded at roughly $280 greater than these on Binance for a similar December 2023 expiration. In the end, the day-to-day pricing of BTC futures contracts hinges on a number of variables. Whereas CME’s buying and selling volumes are trending upward, its pricing mechanism won’t flawlessly mirror Bitcoin’s value actions on crypto exchanges.

Given the intricate interaction of variables impacting its pricing and buying and selling dynamics, it fails to offer enhanced value steering to BTC traders.